Publications » Reports or studies » NERA: Can the steel industry pass through carbon costs without losing market shares?
NERA: Can the steel industry pass through carbon costs without losing market shares?
Downloads and links
Recent updates
The existing EU ETS Directive states that the indicator for the risk of carbon leakage is assessed by “the extent to which it is possible for the sector or subsector concerned, at the relevant level of disaggregation, to pass on the direct cost of the required allowances and the indirect costs from higher electricity prices resulting from the implementation of this Directive into product prices without significant loss of market share to less carbon efficient installations outside the Community”.1
The issue of cost pass-through is thus a critical component of a proper understanding of exposure to the risk of carbon leakage, although it is at best an imperfect indicator. Bearing this in mind, the European Commission (“EC”) released in July 2015 an Impact Assessment, which draws on existing literature, to assess the ability of several sectors to pass through costs, in the context of its Proposal to amend the EU ETS Directive to enhance cost-effective emission reductions and low carbon investments. The EC also commissioned a study by CE Delft / Oeko Institut, which was released in November 2015 and assesses the ability of several sectors to pass through costs.
In this context, EUROFER has asked NERA Economic Consulting to investigate, for the European steel industry, what conclusions can be drawn from the existing literature and the latest study commissioned by the EC, and how this relates to the conclusions of the EC in its Impact Assessment.
Download this publication or visit associated links
Brussels, 10 September 2024 – The Draghi Report thoroughly identifies the bottlenecks to both the EU industry's decarbonisation and competitiveness. The proposed recommendations for energy-intensive industries, including on energy, trade, carbon leakage, financing and lead markets, should be integrated into the upcoming Clean Industrial Deal and implemented with concrete measures as a matter of urgency. Alignment across different policies is crucial, and should be accompanied by sector-specific initiatives to enable the transition of each industry including steel, asks the European Steel Association.
Brussels, 05 September 2024 – The latest developments in the steel sector and across critical value chains are worrying signs of a steady deterioration, endangering the survival and the transition of steelmakers and their key manufacturing customers in Europe, such as automotive. A Clean Industrial Deal including swift and radical measures in EU industrial, energy and trade policies, is the last chance to ensure Europe’s prosperity and shield European industry from cheap imports driven by third countries’ unfair trade practices, overcapacity and lower climate ambition, urges the European Steel Association.
Brussels, 25 July 2024 – Major indicators in the European steel market show a steeper-than-expected downward trend, further impacting the outlook for this year and the next. Poor demand conditions, driven by ongoing factors such as high energy prices, persistent inflation, economic uncertainty and geopolitical tensions, are exacerbated by a manufacturing crisis affecting the largest steel-using sectors, including construction and automotive. According to EUROFER’s latest Economic and Steel Market Outlook, apparent steel consumption is further deteriorating. After a slump (-3.1%) in the first quarter of 2024, its rebound for the full year has been revised downwards (to +1.4% from +3.2%), as well as for 2025 (+4.1% from +5.6%). Similarly, output in steel-using sectors, after a decline in the first quarter (-1.9%), is projected to experience a deeper-than-expected recession (-1.6% from -1%). A recovery is anticipated only in 2025 (+2.3%). Steel imports continue to show historically high shares (27%).